The modern housewife has at her disposal so many household helpers that hard work sometimes turns into pleasure. This also applies to cleaning. A brand new vacuum cleaner will make it easy to clean the house. Modern devices allow not only collecting dust, but also purifying the air in the apartment.
But which vacuum cleaner to choose - with a bag or container? This question sometimes leads to a dead end. Both modifications have both positive and negative aspects.
We have studied all the characteristics and will help you understand which vacuum cleaner is best for the home: with a bag or with a container.
Vacuum cleaners with bags
This is the most common type of harvesting machines. A distinctive feature is a special bag into which dirt and debris gets in the process.
If you decide to buy such a vacuum cleaner, there will be plenty to choose from. There are so many models from different manufacturers on the market that they simply run their eyes. "Bag" vacuum cleaners are vertical and horizontal. They know how to clean carpets, furniture, parquet floors, curtains and other household items.
The only difference lies in what type of bag is presented in a particular model. They are disposable or reusable. The former are made of thick paper or synthetics and are capable of displacing up to 6 kg of dust and debris. After the container is full, the bag is simply thrown away. The second are made of fabric and empty as they fill. Some models have "bags" that can be washed.
Classic dust bags with a dust bag have certain advantages:
- a large selection and variety of models;
- convenient and easy to use;
- have several levels of power adjustment;
- do not require additional effort after each use;
- getting rid of garbage consists in simply throwing away the bag (if it is disposable);
- almost every configuration includes a fabric dust container.
The "baggy" cleaners also have disadvantages:
- clouds of dust when emptying the fabric version of the bag;
- if you do not want to delve into dirt and dust regularly, you will have to regularly buy disposable bags;
- reusable dust bags can wear out and tear over time, and finding a new one is difficult;
- as the container fills up, the suction power drops significantly.
Given all the shortcomings, many housewives give preference to equipment equipped with a container. But do they have advantages? Let's figure it out.
Vacuum cleaner with container
“Bagless” appliances equipped with containers are considered newer and more advanced. Their work was appreciated by clean housekeepers.
The principle of operation of such a device is based on a vortex cycle. The air is sucked into the inside of the device by a powerful flow and moves in a circle, pressing the particles of dirt and dust to the walls of the container, and then it is discharged outside through the filter system. Sometimes container vacuum cleaners have as many as 2 tanks. In the first, larger debris is retained, and in the second, finer cleaning occurs and dust is retained.
Advantages of container models:
- dirt is removed very simply, for this it is enough to shake out the contents of the container into a bucket;
- no additional costs for the purchase of bags;
- even with a filled container, the suction power does not decrease;
- the containers are made of transparent plastic and you can easily notice the necessary thing accidentally got there.
Disadvantages:
- such devices are noisier than “bagged” ones;
- many models do not provide for regulation of the suction power;
- large solid parts falling into the container can scratch it or even break;
- filters clog quickly enough, and their replacement will cost more than buying a new bag;
- after each cleaning, rinse and thoroughly dry the dust bag;
- Poorly assembled models can accumulate static electricity and have a slight shock.
Important:
Important! Paper bags are much preferable in terms of hygiene. They retain 99.9% of all dust and do not need to be shaken out.
Comparison of characteristics
So that the buyer can reasonably decide which cleaning device is better, let's make a few comparisons.
Ease of maintenance and practical use
If we consider the models from the point of view of ease of maintenance, a vacuum cleaner with a paper disposable bag has a clear advantage. Such a device does not need to be washed, dry the container and clean the filters. the filled bag is easy enough to disconnect and throw it into the garbage can. All preparation for work is to insert the bag and plug the vacuum cleaner into the outlet. Taking into account the fact that disposable bags will have to be thrown away regularly, it is better to choose a model for which consumables are easy to find in the store. An excellent option would be a vacuum cleaner with a universal dust collector.
The container cyclone unit will need to be washed and wiped dry after each use. Otherwise, you run the risk of "settling" microbes and mold in it. This is easy to do. You just need to throw dirt into the bucket and rinse the tank under a stream of cool water. Regular cleaning or even replacement will require a filter. However, this process also does not require much effort.
Which vacuum cleaner cleans better
From this point of view, vacuum cleaners with a container are in the lead. Even with a full dust collector, the force of suction of dirt does not change. While for "bag" units, the efficiency of work directly depends on how much the bag is filled. The fuller the capacity, the worse the cleaning quality.
For rooms where dirt builds up quickly, bagless vacuum cleaners are the best option. The dust suction power drops in them only in one case - when the filtering elements located in front of the engine become clogged quite strongly. More often this happens when sufficiently light and long villi are clogged into it: hair, cat hairs, threads, feathers, etc.
Which vacuum cleaner is more hygienic to use
This question is very important, especially in those cases when there are babies in the house or someone from the family has allergies.
It is believed that units with a bag clean the air better. The porous structure of the dust collector itself is an additional filter and does not let the smallest dust particles back through. The moment of truth comes when you have to clean the vacuum cleaner. It is good if the bag is disposable. It can be simply thrown away and is the most hygienic option.But if the dust collector is reusable and you have to shake it out, the pleasure drops to below average. There is no time for hygiene.
Container vacuum cleaners are much better in this regard. Of course, they also have to be cleaned. But firstly, the garbage will be collected in just one cleaning, and not in a whole month, and secondly, there is no need to knock out the container, scattering dust around itself. Just rinse it with water.
The nuances of working with devices of both types
If you decide to opt for a vacuum cleaner with a bag, you should approach the purchase of the latter very responsibly. Poor-quality consumables of an unknown manufacturer can hold dust particles poorly and instead of cleaning you will simply drive the garbage from corner to corner. In case of careless handling, the bags break or move. A loose litter bag negates all efforts to clean the house.
Important:
Attention! Turn on the vacuum cleaner, do not making sure the presence of a dust bag is prohibited. This will result in device failure..
Care should also be taken when working with the containerized machine. They sometimes electric shock. Of course, this is not dangerous, but extremely unpleasant. This happens due to the fact that plastic parts are gradually charged from the friction of particles of debris with static electricity. This cannot be prevented, just be careful.
And also to work with container units, regular filter replacement is required. Before you buy such a vacuum cleaner, ask how easy it is to buy supplies and how much it costs. However, there are the latest generation cyclone vacuum cleaners in which, thanks to their special design, filter replacement is not required.
Price
"Bag" models are very diverse in price. Depending on the size of the buyer's wallet, you can choose a model costing from 100 to 1,000 or more US $. The price of consumables also depends on the model. On average, you will have to spend an additional $ 2-3 per quarter, which, in general, is not enough.
Cyclone vacuum cleaners cost about the same. On the market you can find both expensive and cheap models. But the price of consumables is significantly different. You will have to spend from 10 to 200 $ to purchase new filters, but you will have to make expenses every couple of years or even less.
Given all of the above, it can be argued that among the budget models is better, it turns out to be a vacuum cleaner with a bag. But if you are willing to pay more, you should choose a good multicyclone model. An inexpensive container-type device will perform its functions not so well, and it will not work for so long.
However, having evaluated all the pros and cons, as well as weighing their financial capabilities, each buyer will be able to independently decide which vacuum cleaner to choose - with a bag or a container.